r/feanordidnothingwrong
A subreddit dedicated to the creator of the Silmarils themselves, Fëanor son of Finwë.
How to think about r/feanordidnothingwrong
This community is dedicated to discussing and defending the character Fëanor from J.R.R. Tolkien's legendarium, particularly his actions and motivations in 'The Silmarillion.' Members engage in debates about his legacy, often portraying him as a misunderstood hero rather than a villain. The community's distinctiveness lies in its passionate defense of Fëanor against common criticisms, fostering a unique narrative around his character.
Confidence 4/5
Audience
Participants in this community are typically fans of Tolkien's works, particularly 'The Silmarillion,' and range from casual readers to dedicated scholars. They are often younger adults who enjoy engaging in discussions about character morality and storytelling. The vibe is generally light-hearted yet passionate, with members caring deeply about the nuances of Tolkien's characters and their implications in the broader mythos.
Posting culture
Content that thrives includes memes, in-depth character analyses, and humorous takes on Fëanor's actions. Members appreciate creativity and wit, often favoring posts that challenge conventional views of Fëanor. Downvoted content typically includes overly critical perspectives on Fëanor or posts that lack originality. The posting cadence is moderate, with a mix of daily discussions and periodic meme-sharing.
Brand engagement notes
Brands looking to engage with this community should approach with caution, as overt promotion is often met with skepticism. Authenticity is key; brands could consider sponsoring discussions or creating content that resonates with the community's themes, such as creativity or innovation. Collaborating with members on fan art or character analyses could foster goodwill, but brands should avoid any direct sales pitches or insincere marketing tactics that could alienate the audience.
Top keywords
What r/feanordidnothingwrong talks about
Weighted by how often each term appears in posts and comments, relative to baseline frequency. The largest words are the strongest signals of community focus.
External signals
Where the community looks
Top external domains linked from posts and comments — a quick read on the sources of truth this audience trusts.
Top contributors
Who shapes the conversation
The most active and most-upvoted posters and commenters in this community. Useful when planning outreach or studying a community's tastemakers.
Top posters
By post count
- u/LongGrade881
- u/YakutskPaloAlto
- u/Affectionate_Fox_288
- u/maglorbythesea
- u/SexWithYanfeiSexer69
- u/Careful-Ad8363
- u/SambG98
- u/realunrealdimi
- u/Benadoop-comberflap
- u/kinslayer_3
- u/FeanorDefenseLawyer
- u/AndChronology
- u/rogue63
- u/Genealogy_Chronology
- u/Muppy_N2
- u/GlitteringTone6425
- u/Sonseeahrai
- u/Celebrimbor333
- u/htmlrulezduds
- u/DueAdhesiveness8617
- u/fantasychica37
- u/CanadianCultureKings
- u/Vast_Cauliflower_834
By votes
- u/LongGrade881
- u/Affectionate_Fox_288
- u/maglorbythesea
- u/SexWithYanfeiSexer69
- u/Careful-Ad8363
- u/SambG98
- u/realunrealdimi
- u/Benadoop-comberflap
- u/kinslayer_3
- u/FeanorDefenseLawyer
- u/AndChronology
- u/rogue63
- u/YakutskPaloAlto
- u/Genealogy_Chronology
- u/Muppy_N2
- u/GlitteringTone6425
- u/Sonseeahrai
- u/Celebrimbor333
- u/htmlrulezduds
- u/DueAdhesiveness8617
- u/fantasychica37
- u/Vast_Cauliflower_834
- u/CanadianCultureKings
Top commenters
By comment count
- u/YakutskPaloAlto
- u/[deleted]
- u/allthecactifindahome
- u/MajorJerk77
- u/kinslayer_3
- u/BarbieBaratheon
- u/Shisesen
- u/fantasychica37
- u/SummanusInvictus
- u/richardwhereat
- u/A_pawl_to_adorno
- u/OctaneLoL
- u/Feanor_the_great
- u/divine-ape-swine
- u/John_weak_the_third
- u/PinkyTheDuck
- u/Soft_Needleworker494
- u/MrsDaegmundSwinsere
- u/curufinwe_atarinke
- u/DepreciatedSelfImage
- u/Boarpelt
- u/ATBiB
- u/TheRealOGBobbyB
- u/Reddzoi
- u/Pannbenet
- u/BigRig642018
- u/Ithorianforeplay
- u/Maedhros-Maitimo
- u/MyFrogEatsPeople
- u/telerislayer
- u/FeanaroBot
- u/moonlicious91
- u/scarrafone
- u/Broker112
- u/JetpackKiwi
- u/GroovyGrove
- u/f0rm0r
- u/1ClickDestiny
- u/LFMichigan
- u/sooybeans
- u/garfobo
- u/Willing-Produce5018
- u/1Uplift
- u/Lordluizz
- u/FeanorNoldor
- u/Monumentmendez
- u/gilgalads
- u/rougesubs
- u/stars-glow-softly
- u/oneusrtorulethemall
- u/Xi-feng
- u/TheMeesRunner
- u/karel_gott_mit_uns
- u/jad_alba167
- u/Serious-Ad-513
- u/cally_777
- u/Damascus_ari
- u/SydneyCartonLived
- u/AndChronology
- u/bearfifty
- u/Lolmanmagee
- u/Genealogy_Chronology
- u/likac05
- u/toofatofly
- u/Muppy_N2
- u/Fallenman7
- u/EldritchX78
- u/kimbeeisMYname
- u/General__Obvious
- u/Electrical-Try585
- u/Lazy-Adeptness-2343
- u/MothInsideJar
- u/FlyingFrog99
- u/Upbeat-Education-245
- u/realunrealdimi
- u/Special-Remove-3294
- u/TheBirdologist
- u/HenriettaCactus
By votes
- u/MajorJerk77
- u/General__Obvious
- u/PinkyTheDuck
- u/Electrical-Try585
- u/TheRealOGBobbyB
- u/YakutskPaloAlto
- u/A_pawl_to_adorno
- u/BarbieBaratheon
- u/OctaneLoL
- u/1Uplift
- u/Shisesen
- u/Muppy_N2
- u/SummanusInvictus
- u/kinslayer_3
- u/allthecactifindahome
- u/FeanaroBot
- u/f0rm0r
- u/Fallenman7
- u/Lazy-Adeptness-2343
- u/[deleted]
- u/curufinwe_atarinke
- u/1ClickDestiny
- u/HenriettaCactus
- u/MrsDaegmundSwinsere
- u/EldritchX78
- u/DepreciatedSelfImage
- u/gilgalads
- u/moonlicious91
- u/kimbeeisMYname
- u/MyFrogEatsPeople
- u/LFMichigan
- u/rougesubs
- u/stars-glow-softly
- u/AndChronology
- u/FlyingFrog99
- u/Maedhros-Maitimo
- u/oneusrtorulethemall
- u/SydneyCartonLived
- u/TheBirdologist
- u/sooybeans
- u/Lordluizz
- u/Lolmanmagee
- u/Feanor_the_great
- u/Upbeat-Education-245
- u/realunrealdimi
- u/Pannbenet
- u/garfobo
- u/Special-Remove-3294
- u/divine-ape-swine
- u/richardwhereat
- u/FeanorNoldor
- u/Boarpelt
- u/Reddzoi
- u/BigRig642018
- u/fantasychica37
- u/scarrafone
- u/Broker112
- u/Xi-feng
- u/TheMeesRunner
- u/karel_gott_mit_uns
- u/Genealogy_Chronology
- u/ATBiB
- u/JetpackKiwi
- u/Monumentmendez
- u/jad_alba167
- u/bearfifty
- u/MothInsideJar
- u/John_weak_the_third
- u/Ithorianforeplay
- u/telerislayer
- u/GroovyGrove
- u/Willing-Produce5018
- u/Serious-Ad-513
- u/cally_777
- u/Damascus_ari
- u/Soft_Needleworker494
- u/likac05
- u/toofatofly
Similar communities
Where this audience also spends time
Topic-adjacent communities surfaced from Reddit's own related subreddit signal.
FAQ
r/feanordidnothingwrong — frequently asked questions
Quick facts about this subreddit's size, history, focus, and related communities.
How many subscribers does r/feanordidnothingwrong have?
r/feanordidnothingwrong has approximately 8,244 subscribers as of May 27, 2026.
When was r/feanordidnothingwrong created?
r/feanordidnothingwrong was created on July 26, 2018 (8 years ago).
What is r/feanordidnothingwrong about?
This community is dedicated to discussing and defending the character Fëanor from J.R.R. Tolkien's legendarium, particularly his actions and motivations in 'The Silmarillion.' Members engage in debates about his legacy, often portraying him as a misunderstood hero rather than a villain. The community's distinctiveness lies in its passionate defense of Fëanor against common c…
What subreddits are similar to r/feanordidnothingwrong?
Communities similar to r/feanordidnothingwrong include r/thesilmarillion, r/lotrbookmemes, r/saurondidnothingwrong, r/tolkienmemes, r/quenya.
Who are the most active posters on r/feanordidnothingwrong?
The most frequent posters on r/feanordidnothingwrong include u/LongGrade881, u/YakutskPaloAlto, u/Affectionate_Fox_288.
Ready to engage on r/feanordidnothingwrong?
Authentic engagement, not spam.
RedPulse runs Reddit campaigns the way the platform actually rewards — high-karma accounts, native conversations, and content moderators welcome.
