r/breakingamish
A subreddit dedicated to the TLC reality show Breaking Amish and it's sister show, Return to Amish.
How to think about r/breakingamish
The community focuses on discussions surrounding the TLC reality shows Breaking Amish and its sequel, Return to Amish. Members share insights, critiques, and personal reflections on the lives of the Amish individuals featured in the series, often exploring themes of cultural conflict, identity, and the challenges faced by those who leave the Amish lifestyle. The tone is often informal and can be humorous, reflecting the sometimes absurd situations portrayed in the shows.
Confidence 4/5
Audience
Participants are typically fans of reality television, particularly those interested in the dynamics of Amish culture and the personal stories of its members. The audience skews towards adults, many of whom enjoy discussing the dramatic elements of the shows and the real-life implications of leaving the Amish community. The vibe is generally light-hearted, with a mix of curiosity and critique regarding the show's portrayal of its subjects.
Posting culture
Content that thrives includes episode recaps, character analyses, and humorous commentary on the show's events. Members often engage in lively discussions, sharing memes and reactions to the latest episodes. Posts that come across as overly promotional or lacking in substance may receive downvotes. The community values authenticity and personal insights, leading to a culture where regular participation and timely posts around new episodes are encouraged.
Brand engagement notes
Brands looking to engage with this community should focus on authenticity and relatability rather than overt promotion. Content that resonates includes discussions about the cultural aspects of the Amish lifestyle or the impact of reality TV on personal identity. Brands should avoid direct advertising or promotional posts, as members may react negatively to perceived insincerity. Instead, engaging in conversations and sharing relevant, thoughtful content can foster a positive reception.
Top keywords
What r/breakingamish talks about
Weighted by how often each term appears in posts and comments, relative to baseline frequency. The largest words are the strongest signals of community focus.
External signals
Where the community looks
Top external domains linked from posts and comments — a quick read on the sources of truth this audience trusts.
Top contributors
Who shapes the conversation
The most active and most-upvoted posters and commenters in this community. Useful when planning outreach or studying a community's tastemakers.
Top posters
By post count
- u/LittleEmmy
- u/peytoncoooke
- u/EtM1980
- u/Stella430
- u/SexySassySouthern
- u/brehan8
- u/ZealousidealDeer3007
- u/Jacayrie
- u/Amethyst939
- u/LuckyJournalist7
- u/[deleted]
- u/Rich-Fix-841
- u/miss_night_owl
- u/lezzeroni
- u/LilacPenny
- u/keyboardtherapist
- u/lisawl7tr
- u/Responsible-Study611
- u/mSoGood08
- u/FlgurlinAz
- u/UncaringNonchalance
- u/stanky-hanky-panky
- u/Lazy-Volume-4012
- u/Ambitious-Quarter-13
- u/LostintheLand
- u/Lioness_106
- u/DreamsAndBoxes
- u/amethystrosegold
- u/MyDogSmellsLikeMyCat
- u/brownah22
- u/apaw1129
- u/Bishuout
- u/carolinababy2
- u/essenceofdairy
- u/aubtronics
- u/Fickle-Knowledge6214
- u/Fantastic-Artist-789
- u/Bhood619
- u/silveracidreign
- u/Neat-Spray9660
- u/HisGirl
- u/jackson_jupiter_666
- u/DeitzNutzUrMom
- u/peacefulvanessa30
- u/BinxieBear
- u/vegasbeck
- u/External-Kiwi3371
- u/kelleythursday
- u/BigDee2k
- u/Greenveins
- u/mummyandwife
- u/HelenaBirkinBag
- u/Honest_Ad_9169
- u/MSCCCLP
- u/krxstxnnn
- u/Strange_Following261
- u/tiedyediva
- u/MarshaHurl
- u/popcornkernals321
- u/Dramas_mama
- u/Confident_Pie3995
- u/GlitteringExplorer90
- u/mysteryman28
- u/BaconSlapFroco
By votes
- u/miss_night_owl
- u/LittleEmmy
- u/EtM1980
- u/lezzeroni
- u/Stella430
- u/ZealousidealDeer3007
- u/LilacPenny
- u/keyboardtherapist
- u/SexySassySouthern
- u/brehan8
- u/lisawl7tr
- u/Responsible-Study611
- u/mSoGood08
- u/Jacayrie
- u/FlgurlinAz
- u/UncaringNonchalance
- u/stanky-hanky-panky
- u/LostintheLand
- u/peytoncoooke
- u/Ambitious-Quarter-13
- u/Lazy-Volume-4012
- u/Amethyst939
- u/DreamsAndBoxes
- u/amethystrosegold
- u/MyDogSmellsLikeMyCat
- u/Lioness_106
- u/brownah22
- u/apaw1129
- u/Bishuout
- u/essenceofdairy
- u/carolinababy2
- u/aubtronics
- u/Fickle-Knowledge6214
- u/Fantastic-Artist-789
- u/Bhood619
- u/silveracidreign
- u/HisGirl
- u/jackson_jupiter_666
- u/Neat-Spray9660
- u/LuckyJournalist7
- u/BinxieBear
- u/DeitzNutzUrMom
- u/peacefulvanessa30
- u/vegasbeck
- u/kelleythursday
- u/External-Kiwi3371
- u/BigDee2k
- u/Greenveins
- u/[deleted]
- u/mummyandwife
- u/HelenaBirkinBag
- u/Honest_Ad_9169
- u/MSCCCLP
- u/tiedyediva
- u/MarshaHurl
- u/krxstxnnn
- u/Strange_Following261
- u/popcornkernals321
- u/Confident_Pie3995
- u/Dramas_mama
- u/GlitteringExplorer90
- u/mysteryman28
- u/Rich-Fix-841
- u/BaconSlapFroco
Top commenters
By comment count
- u/FunFactress
- u/AceSpadeofVentura
- u/BurningandChurning
- u/LuckyJournalist7
- u/nola_karen
- u/thepeoplessgt
- u/Amethyst939
- u/imsadbutitswhatever
- u/Stupidsexyflanders61
- u/ConversationThick379
- u/Blueberry-farm
- u/Fuhdawin
- u/International-Big170
- u/GentleHermit
- u/[deleted]
- u/apaw1129
- u/Livinlifegood4evr
- u/Southern-Fried-Biker
- u/LockITdown444
- u/mime454
- u/moekay
- u/Jacayrie
- u/GlitteringExplorer90
- u/BlettaFappaChu
- u/beebyspice
- u/EtM1980
- u/Altruistic-Nose-52
- u/ChoochiCastro
- u/DoTheRightThing1976
- u/dgallagh
- u/QuesoFajitas
- u/darladee1234
- u/forevrtwntyfour
- u/Normal-Fall2821
- u/piperpit
- u/Totin_it
- u/Different_Falcon8596
- u/AB2019716
- u/Dramas_mama
- u/splanchnick78
- u/Lioness_106
- u/PsychoTink
- u/jewboojew
- u/No-Union-8895
- u/renees24
- u/poshdog4444
- u/Formal-Blackberry-49
- u/glimmerskies
- u/BrulesJules
- u/AlexaPomegranate
- u/Protection_Major
- u/Princess-Soprano
- u/b1tchbhigh
- u/Purple_Grass_5300
- u/PermitPast1903
- u/Ok_Recipe2871
- u/LostintheLand
- u/bitchgh0st
- u/gidlub
- u/carpentersglue
- u/bickybb
- u/HoneyBeeAlchemy
- u/Global_Fix1083
- u/Difficult-Factor583
- u/arlo-ve
- u/rhodeislandah
- u/Effective_Baby_4748
- u/MSMOKER37
- u/Freespirited92
- u/Leftturn0619
- u/Temporary_Ice2027
- u/maisymowse
- u/After_Preference_885
- u/hoosiergirl1962
- u/senoritageena
- u/Salazarasaurus13
- u/Genchuto
- u/Brilliant-Blood-7461
- u/Parade2thegrave
- u/annmargrock1
- u/Logical_Boss_2951
- u/Proud_Internet_Troll
- u/missfeline99
- u/TestingMurphysLaw
- u/GundumForceAlpha
- u/Odd_Produce_7592
- u/Prestigious_Vast_195
- u/Nature_Walk_299
- u/kaf1007
- u/Orangebluesky
- u/Zestyclose-Angle4378
- u/CryBySmiling
- u/brifiguy
- u/WhitsSwirlyKnee
- u/polerize
- u/Narfle_da_Garthok
- u/Kitchen_Body3215
- u/URqweAN
- u/catlady7667
- u/gotyeah-1111
By votes
- u/FunFactress
- u/AceSpadeofVentura
- u/BurningandChurning
- u/LuckyJournalist7
- u/thepeoplessgt
- u/nola_karen
- u/Amethyst939
- u/Fuhdawin
- u/imsadbutitswhatever
- u/ConversationThick379
- u/Blueberry-farm
- u/International-Big170
- u/GentleHermit
- u/LockITdown444
- u/hoosiergirl1962
- u/ChoochiCastro
- u/apaw1129
- u/Southern-Fried-Biker
- u/[deleted]
- u/Altruistic-Nose-52
- u/moekay
- u/annmargrock1
- u/Jacayrie
- u/mullabear
- u/EtM1980
- u/piperpit
- u/Dramas_mama
- u/splanchnick78
- u/PsychoTink
- u/renees24
- u/dgallagh
- u/darladee1234
- u/LostintheLand
- u/Unlucky-Paint-1545
- u/maisymowse
- u/Totin_it
- u/rhodeislandah
- u/Stupidsexyflanders61
- u/Protection_Major
- u/Purple_Grass_5300
- u/mime454
- u/cklw1
- u/Effective_Baby_4748
- u/bitchgh0st
- u/Global_Fix1083
- u/GlitteringExplorer90
- u/glimmerskies
- u/Zestyclose-Angle4378
- u/oooheycait1223
- u/Princess-Soprano
- u/gidlub
- u/Lioness_106
- u/No-Union-8895
- u/poshdog4444
- u/moth--foot
- u/Formal-Blackberry-49
- u/b1tchbhigh
- u/ren_is_here_
- u/Parade2thegrave
- u/BlettaFappaChu
- u/Freespirited92
- u/kaf1007
- u/QuesoFajitas
- u/jewboojew
- u/Difficult-Factor583
- u/llcmomx3
- u/zeppnnon
- u/lilbopeep1235
- u/FlgurlinAz
- u/senoritageena
- u/No_Reward_843
- u/Different_Falcon8596
- u/tinalpasid
- u/Confident_Pie3995
- u/Kontos_Stelio
- u/Environmental_Size41
- u/TestingMurphysLaw
- u/CryBySmiling
- u/Cultural_Toe37
- u/carpentersglue
- u/Tuff_Wizardess
- u/Lex_Loki
- u/beebyspice
- u/jaxblack7
- u/saddestgirl1995
- u/SexySassySouthern
- u/arlo-ve
- u/Temporary_Ice2027
- u/Wolverine_2323
- u/BrulesJules
- u/forevrtwntyfour
- u/Snoobs-Magoo
- u/tomatilloarmadillo
- u/AW-43
- u/missfeline99
- u/DoTheRightThing1976
- u/gotyeah-1111
- u/HoneyBeeAlchemy
- u/onlyastoner
- u/Proud_Internet_Troll
Similar communities
Where this audience also spends time
Topic-adjacent communities surfaced from Reddit's own related subreddit signal.
FAQ
r/breakingamish — frequently asked questions
Quick facts about this subreddit's size, history, focus, and related communities.
How many subscribers does r/breakingamish have?
r/breakingamish has approximately 9,211 subscribers as of May 27, 2026.
When was r/breakingamish created?
r/breakingamish was created on September 26, 2012 (14 years ago).
What is r/breakingamish about?
The community focuses on discussions surrounding the TLC reality shows Breaking Amish and its sequel, Return to Amish. Members share insights, critiques, and personal reflections on the lives of the Amish individuals featured in the series, often exploring themes of cultural conflict, identity, and the challenges faced by those who leave the Amish lifestyle. The tone is ofte…
What subreddits are similar to r/breakingamish?
Communities similar to r/breakingamish include r/7littlejohnstons, r/mamajunefromnottohot, r/1000lbsisters, r/evilliveshere, r/extremesisters.
Who are the most active posters on r/breakingamish?
The most frequent posters on r/breakingamish include u/LittleEmmy, u/peytoncoooke, u/EtM1980.
Ready to engage on r/breakingamish?
Authentic engagement, not spam.
RedPulse runs Reddit campaigns the way the platform actually rewards — high-karma accounts, native conversations, and content moderators welcome.
